Last week, Jordan Peterson stepped into a YouTube arena hosted by Jubilee for a discussion initially titled “1 Christian vs 20 Atheists,” later renamed “Jordan Peterson vs 20 Atheists” after he refused to clarify his beliefs. The event promised a defense of Christian faith, but Peterson’s performance was vague, irritable, and devoid of clear theological conviction, leaving the conversation directionless. Peterson leans on psychological interpretations of biblical stories, avoiding the historical and theological claims central to Christianity. His refusal to affirm Christ’s divinity or resurrection offers no apology for the faith, only abstract musings that left both atheists and believers wanting.
Around the same time, the passing of Phil Robertson, the Duck Dynasty patriarch, marked the loss of a man who stood in stark contrast to Peterson’s cerebral ambiguity. Robertson, who died yesterday, was a plain-spoken, camouflage-clad figure whose unpolished demeanor masked a profound wisdom rooted in his love for Jesus Christ. Known for his blunt proclamation of the gospel, he captured hearts not through academic credentials but through a life transformed by faith. His wealth, built from a duck call empire, could have overshadowed Peterson’s, yet he remained humble, grounded in his devotion to Christ. While Robertson held to Campbellite views on baptism, which we definitely ought to question, we trust God’s grace, through Christ’s blood, covers such doctrinal errors that don’t have one believing in the wrong God or trusting in their own works for salvation (1 John 1:7). This aside, Robertson’s life embodied the biblical truth that God “has hidden these things from the wise and learned, and revealed them to little children” (Matthew 11:25).
THE TWO WISE MEN
The contrast between Peterson and Robertson illuminates a biblical theme: God exalts the humble and confounds the wise. As 1 Corinthians 1:27 declares, “God chose the foolish things of the world to shame the wise; God chose the weak things of the world to shame the strong.” Peterson, with his academic pedigree and global platform, represents the “wise” of this age—knowledgeable but often lacking the deeper wisdom that comes from submitting to Christ. Robertson, mocked by some as a “swamp hillbilly,” was lifted up by God because he exalted Christ, fulfilling James 4:10: “Humble yourselves before the Lord, and he will lift you up.” Peterson’s faltering debate and Robertson’s death is a lens to explore how true wisdom, rooted in faith, surpasses intellectual sophistication.
Peterson rose to fame through his lectures on psychology and mythology, amplified by his book 12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos and a YouTube channel with millions of views. He’s celebrated for defending Western values tied to the “Judeo-Christian ethic,” but his approach to Christianity is far from orthodox. He sees the Bible as a collection of psychological archetypes, not divine revelation. In his lectures, he frames stories like Adam and Eve or Cain and Abel as insights into human behavior, but he avoids affirming their historical or theological truth. He once described the cross as “the point of greatest suffering, the point of death and transformation, and the symbolic centre of the world.” This poetic take sidesteps the resurrection, which Paul calls the cornerstone of faith: “If Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile” (1 Corinthians 15:17). In the Jubilee debate, Peterson’s refusal to clarify his beliefs frustrated participants, offering nothing tangible to debate. He appeared lost, unable to bridge his intellectual insights with the gospel’s transformative power.
Peterson’s intellectualism, while impressive, often leaves him adrift in questions without answers. He’s called the Bible “unutterably deep,” admitting that reducing religious beliefs to biology always leaves “something left over that you haven’t explained.” Yet, instead of embracing this as evidence of divine truth, he remains evasive, once saying he needed “three more years” to answer whether he believes in Christ’s resurrection. This aligns with 1 Corinthians 3:19: “The wisdom of this world is foolishness in God’s sight.” His knowledge is vast, but without Christ’s anchor, it becomes what Ecclesiastes 1:17 calls “a chasing after the wind.” In the debate, he offered no clear path to faith, leaving atheists unchallenged and believers disheartened, a far cry from the bold defense expected.
Phil Robertson, by contrast, was a man of simplicity and certainty. Born in rural Louisiana, he lived a rough early life of drinking and carousing before a dramatic conversion in his late 20s. His encounter with Christ transformed him from a barroom brawler to a gospel preacher, a story he shared unapologetically on Duck Dynasty and beyond. Unlike Peterson, Robertson needed no academic jargon. He spoke plainly, as Jesus instructed in Matthew 5:37: “Let your ‘Yes’ be ‘Yes,’ and your ‘No,’ ‘No.’” His faith was a lived reality, not a philosophical exercise. He once said he was a “low-tech man in a high-tech world,” but he had “a high-tech Savior.” His preaching cut through pretense, proclaiming Jesus as the only path to salvation, echoing John 14:6: “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.” His simplicity reflected Psalm 119:130: “The unfolding of your words gives light; it gives understanding to the simple.”
Robertson’s wisdom came not from degrees but from his relationship with Christ. While elites might scoff at his rural roots, God exalted him because he exalted Jesus. As Luke 16:15 warns, “What people value highly is detestable in God’s sight.” Robertson’s life proved this, as his plain-spoken faith touched millions, from TV viewers to churchgoers. He faced cancel culture—most notably in 2013 when A&E briefly suspended him for his biblical views on marriage—but he stood firm, saying, “I’d rather be biblically correct than politically correct.” His courage mirrored 1 Peter 3:15: “Always be prepared to give an answer… for the hope that you have.” Unlike Peterson, who dodged definitive truth claims, Robertson’s clarity led many to faith, fulfilling Matthew 5:16: “Let your light shine before others, that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in heaven.”
THE WISDOM OF THE SIMPLE
The Bible consistently contrasts worldly wisdom with divine understanding. Peterson, for all his erudition, exemplifies the former—knowledgeable but often blind to eternal truths. His approach to faith is cerebral, viewing God as a psychological necessity rather than the living Creator. He’s described religious belief as “a mode of being” rather than a set of truth claims, which aligns with his debate performance: articulate but aimless. This reflects 1 Corinthians 2:14: “The person without the Spirit does not accept the things that come from the Spirit of God but considers them foolishness.” Peterson’s reluctance to embrace Christ’s resurrection or divinity leaves him “a blind guide,” leading others to questions but rarely to answers.
Robertson, conversely, embodied the wisdom God grants to the humble. His conversion story—surrendering a life of sin to follow Christ—mirrored the transformation Paul describes in 2 Corinthians 5:17: “If anyone is in Christ, the new creation has come: The old has gone, the new is here!” He didn’t need to parse archetypes; he knew Jesus as Savior. His preaching, often delivered in a duck blind or church pew, carried the weight of lived experience, not theoretical musings. As Proverbs 9:10 states, “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom.” Robertson’s fear of God, coupled with his love for Christ, made him wise in ways Peterson’s lectures never could. While Peterson influenced intellectuals, Robertson reached the common man, proving God’s promise in Psalm 25:9: “He guides the humble in what is right and teaches them his way.”
THE INFLUENCE OF FAITH
Both men faced cultural battles, but their approaches differed sharply. Peterson, a darling of conservative intellectuals, has been a lightning rod for cancel culture, particularly for his critiques of political correctness and gender ideology. His defiance earned him a following among those seeking clarity in a chaotic world. Yet his influence often stops at the philosophical, offering tools for personal responsibility but no ultimate hope. As he once said, “Life is suffering,” a truth he draws from biblical narratives but frames without the redemptive hope of Christ’s victory over sin and death. His followers may find order in his “clean your room” mantra, but without Christ, it’s a Sisyphean task, as Ecclesiastes 2:11 warns: “Yet when I surveyed all that my hands had done… everything was meaningless, a chasing after the wind.”
Robertson, too, faced cultural scorn, but his response was rooted in eternal truth. His 2013 suspension from Duck Dynasty sparked outrage among fans, not because he was eloquent but because he was honest. He spoke of sin and salvation without apology, saying, “You’re not going to get to heaven by being good. You get there through Jesus.” His influence extended beyond TV, with countless stories of people coming to faith through his testimony. Unlike Peterson, whose ideas resonate with the “sophisticated,” Robertson’s plain talk reached the heart, fulfilling 1 Corinthians 1:21: “God was pleased through the foolishness of what was preached to save those who believe.” His humility disarmed critics, proving Proverbs 22:4: “Humility is the fear of the Lord; its wages are riches and honor and life.”
THE LIMITS OF INTELLECT
Peterson’s debate with the atheists laid bare the limits of his approach. By refusing to make truth claims, he offered no defense of Christianity, only a series of psychological insights that left the room cold. His view of God as a “useful fiction” or a “meta-truth” may intrigue academics, but it fails to answer the soul’s deepest questions. As Romans 1:22 notes, “Although they claimed to be wise, they became fools.” Peterson’s knowledge of mythology and psychology is vast, but without Christ, it lacks the power to save. His performance echoed the warning of 2 Timothy 3:7—always learning but “never able to come to a knowledge of the truth.” He may lead the intellectual community to ponder life’s meaning, but without the cross, he offers no destination.
Robertson, by contrast, knew the destination. His faith was not in abstract principles but in the person of Jesus. He once said, “If you’re not impressed with the picture of Jesus in the Bible, you’re not paying attention.” His life was a testament to Psalm 19:7: “The law of the Lord is perfect, refreshing the soul. The statutes of the Lord are trustworthy, making wise the simple.” While Peterson’s followers grapple with existential questions, Robertson’s pointed to a clear answer: Christ. His death was not an end but a homecoming, as John 11:25 promises: “I am the resurrection and the life. The one who believes in me will live, even though they die.” His legacy endures in those he led to faith, not through eloquence but through truth.
THE POWER OF HUMILITY
The cultural elite may have looked down on Robertson’s rural roots, but God used his simplicity to confound the wise. His lack of pretense—whether in his camouflage attire or his unfiltered speech—made him relatable, a living example of Matthew 18:4: “Whoever humbles himself like this child is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven.” Peterson, for all his influence, risks becoming a cautionary tale of intellectual pride. His refusal to submit to Christ’s truth leaves him “playing the fool.” Proverbs 26:12 warns, “Do you see a person wise in their own eyes? There is more hope for a fool than for them.” Peterson’s knowledge, untethered from faith, cannot lead to the eternal life Robertson proclaimed.
Both men shared traits—resilience against cultural pressure, a conservative ethos, and a platform to influence millions. But only Robertson’s legacy points to eternal truth. Peterson’s questions, while thought-provoking, leave followers in a maze of meaning. Robertson’s answers, rooted in Christ, offer a map to salvation. As 1 Corinthians 1:18 declares, “The message of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God.” Robertson’s life and death reflect this power, while Peterson’s debate revealed the emptiness of wisdom without faith. In the end, God makes wise the simple, confounds the proud, and exalts those who exalt His Son.
If you appreciate my work, please consider an $8 a month or $80 year subscription to access exclusive content (like the rest of this article).
If you don’t want a subscription, please consider a one-time gift of your choosing by clicking the ‘coffee link’ below. This is one of the things I do to provide for my small farm and big family, so I sure appreciate it.
Share this post