Insight to Incite: Open Source Intelligence Analysis

Insight to Incite: Open Source Intelligence Analysis

The Protestant How-To Guide on Conducting an Exorcism

An Insight to Incite Top-Shelf Preserve

JD Hall's avatar
JD Hall
Oct 12, 2025
∙ Paid

Yes, I’m going to teach you how to conduct an exorcism in the Biblical way. And if that seems crazy (or Catholic), I assure you that long before the Church was commandeered by emperors, it knew how to commandeer people from demons.

The first Christians lived in a world haunted by spirits. Pagan cities were filled with shrines, idols, and charms that promised protection from invisible powers. The early Church did not deny the existence of those powers; it cast them out. The feat that most stunned the ancient world about the new Christian sect was their expulsion of demons by men with no rank, no magic, and no relics. They drove them out with nothing more than faith in the crucified Christ.

The men often cited by Protestant theologians believed in exorcism, every one, down the line. Despite most the Church Fathers being cessationists (believing the Apostolic Sign Gifts had faded by the 2nd Century) a few were outliers on the subject (like Irenaeus and Tertullian) and believed they continued, albeit mostly muted. In fact, on matters of essential Christian doctrine, there was almost always an outlier among them on any subject. It seemed that lacking the inerrancy of their mentors, the Apostles, one of them was almost always wrong. I’ve always been fascinated that fact, that the so-called Fathers appear infallible on important doctrinal matters, but only by consensus, with always a stray vote, here or there.

But amazingly, on the subject of demonic possession and exorcism, even the Cessationists believed in the possession of human bodies and the capacity (and responsibility) of Christians to cast them out. That’s because in their view (which was correct), exorcism wasn’t an Apostolic Sign Gift. If you told that to hyper-cessationists like Justin Peters, they would disagree. But the Scripture is very clear on the subject. In both Mark 9 and Luke 9, we see exorcists successfully casting out demons who the disciples didn’t know, and they did so by Jesus’ name.

And John answered and said, Master, we saw one casting out devils in thy name; and we forbad him, because he followeth not with us. And Jesus said unto him, Forbid him not: for he that is not against us is for us” (Luke 9:49-50).

The Apostolic Sign Gifts are called that, because it’s gifting displayed by the Apostles and upon whom the Apostles laid hands, as a sign to the unbelieving Jews that they had authority granted them by God, substantiating the truth of the gospel’s message. Given that these exorcists were unknown to the disciples, they weren’t among the number of those upon whom the disciples laid hands. What that means is that if exorcism isn’t an Apostolic Sign Gift, then there’s no reason it shouldn’t be done today.

I2I Top Shelf Preserves are preserved for Insight to Incite paid subscribers only.
Almost all articles at I21 are available to the public, and even those with a paywall have at least half the content still available for free. But I2I Top Shelf Preserves are not your average polemics half-open essays. These are the rare vintages, the pieces containing original research, ideological synthesis, and first-hand discovery from JD Hall. When we bottle something this pure, it doesn’t get poured out for free. This is top shelf information to top shelf subscribers.

Get 20% Off to Continue Reading

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of JD Hall.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 JD Hall · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.