Smite Club Independence Day Edition: Rev. John Muhlenberg

Mid sermon, he dramatically threw off his robe to show the congregation that underneath it, was a uniform...and 300 of his churchmen followed him to war.

There are sermons that end in prayer. There are sermons that end in song. And then there was the sermon that ended with a pastor throwing off his clerical robe, revealing a Continental Army uniform underneath, and declaring, “There is a time to preach, and a time to fight.”

That sermon belonged to Rev. John Peter Gabriel Muhlenberg—a fire-baptized, Bible-breathing, sabre-swinging saint who didn’t just thunder about righteousness but dragged it onto a battlefield and let it speak in musket fire. He wasn’t content to stand in a pulpit while devils wore crowns and tyrants wrote laws. No, Muhlenberg took his theology straight to the trenches—and dared hell to blink.

A LUTHERAN WITH A LOADED MUSKET

Born in 1746 to Henry Muhlenberg—the father of American Lutheranism—John Muhlenberg was baptized in Scripture and boldness. Raised in a household where the Bible was more worn than the family table, young John was catechized in Christ and courage. His early education included time in Germany, but his spirit belonged to the frontier, where danger and providence always seemed to walk hand in hand.

He became a preacher, yes, but also a soldier. During the French and Indian War, he joined the British Army as a teenager, because apparently sermons on the wrath of God weren’t spicy enough. By the time he was preaching in Woodstock, Virginia, he was a man on fire—with a burden for truth, a fury for justice, and an itch for battle that no homily could scratch.

THE MOST LEGENDARY SERMON IN AMERICA

January 1776. The colonies crackled with revolution. Tyranny wore a crown, and liberty was on life support. That Sunday, Muhlenberg ascended the pulpit, Bible in hand, and preached on Ecclesiastes 3: “To everything there is a season...” He thundered through the times for peace and for war, righteousness and judgment.

When he reached verse 8—“a time of war, and a time of peace”—he paused. Then, with deliberate motion, he tore off his clerical robe to reveal the blue and buff uniform of a Continental Army officer. The congregation gasped. He stepped from behind the pulpit, sword at his side, and declared, “The time to fight has come!”

The altar became a recruiting station. Over 300 men from his congregation enlisted that day. They didn’t stop to change their Sunday clothes. They followed their pastor from pew to battlefield.

If you’re enjoying the intro to today’s Smite Club article, you’re really gonna like the whole thing. Smite Club articles are only accessible by paid subscribers of Insight to Incite. Thanks to a generous supporter, until the end of July 4, you can subscribe with a 50% discount, but you must act TODAY.